Balancing military service with a civilian job comes with unique challenges, including understanding your rights for time off. Many service members ask: Can your employer make you use PTO for military obligations?
Under federal law, the short answer is no. Protected by the Uniformed Services Employment and Reemployment Rights Act (USERRA), employers cannot force employees to use paid time off (PTO) for military leave unless they choose to. Here’s an in-depth look at USERRA’s protections and your options if your employer isn’t respecting these rights.
Laws That Protect Service Members from Being Forced to Use PTO for Military Obligations
Several federal laws exist to safeguard the employment rights of service members, ensuring they can serve their country without risking their civilian jobs or benefits. These laws cover military duty, military leave, and reemployment rights, including protection against forced PTO use for military service. Here’s a breakdown of the primary laws that protect you:
1. Uniformed Services Employment and Reemployment Rights Act (USERRA)
USERRA is the key federal law protecting service members’ employment rights. Enacted in 1994, this law ensures that individuals serving in the uniformed services (such as the National Guard, Reserves, and other military branches) are not disadvantaged in their civilian careers due to their military obligations. Specifically, USERRA prohibits employers from:
Requiring employees to use PTO or vacation time for military training, active duty, or other periods of service. Instead, employees have the right to unpaid military leave.
Discriminating against employees based on their uniformed service status or obligations.
Denying returning service members reemployment with the same seniority status and pay they would have attained if they had remained continuously employed.
Under USERRA, service members also have the right to retain health plan coverage for up to 24 months and must be promptly reinstated in their civilian jobs upon completion of their period of service.
2. The Veterans’ Benefits Improvement Act (VBIA)
The VBIA of 2004 expanded USERRA’s protections, particularly for returning service members. This law requires employers to provide written notice of the rights and protections available under USERRA. It also reinforces the rights of employees to maintain health plan coverage during their period of service and clarifies that employees are not required to exhaust PTO before taking military leave. Employers are mandated to offer reemployment to service members in a timely manner, meaning as soon as is practically possible upon their return.
3. Servicemembers Civil Relief Act (SCRA)
Although not directly focused on employment, the Servicemembers Civil Relief Act (SCRA) provides critical protections that indirectly support service members’ employment stability. Enacted in 2003, this law assists service members by reducing financial and legal burdens during active duty or military service. SCRA includes provisions for deferred civil obligations, such as loan payments and rent, which can help reduce financial pressure that might otherwise necessitate using PTO while on military duty.
4. National Defense Authorization Act (NDAA)
The NDAA includes several provisions that impact service members and their civilian employment rights, particularly concerning the National Guard and reserve military personnel called up on a voluntary or involuntary basis for military necessity during a national emergency. This act supports job protection measures under USERRA for both voluntary and involuntary service, emphasizing the government’s commitment to maintaining reemployment rights for employees whose military service takes precedence over civilian employment.
5. State Military Leave Laws
While federal laws like USERRA offer broad protections, many states have enacted additional military leave laws that provide further safeguards for service members. These laws vary widely by state but often include:
Requirements for employers to provide paid military leave in addition to unpaid leave, as stipulated by federal law.
Specific provisions for employees of public or government entities, requiring them to retain their pay or PTO balance during military obligations.
Enhanced reemployment rights and protections for reserve military personnel who serve in the National Guard.
Real-Life Cases: When Employers Forced PTO Use and Faced Legal Action
Several real-life cases highlight what can happen when employers violate USERRA by forcing employees to use PTO or vacation days for military duty. Here are two notable examples:
Case Example: Peterson v. Credit Union One (2015)
In this case, Credit Union One required service member Peterson to use his accrued vacation days for his military training obligations with the National Guard. Peterson argued this was a violation of his reemployment rights under USERRA. The court ruled in favor of Peterson, stating that his employer had indeed violated federal military leave laws. Credit Union One was ordered to compensate Peterson for his lost benefits and cover his legal fees.Case Example: Barnes v. Waste Management Inc. (2017)
Waste Management Inc. faced legal action after forcing employee Barnes, a member of the uniformed services, to use PTO during his period of service in the reserves. Barnes filed a claim with the U.S. Department of Labor, which led to a lawsuit. Waste Management settled out of court, reimbursing Barnes for his lost PTO and paying an additional sum for emotional distress.
Steps to Take if You Are a Victim of Being Forced to Use PTO for Military Obligations
If your employer has pressured or forced you to use PTO for military service in violation of your rights under USERRA, here are the steps you can take to protect yourself and seek justice:
Understand Your Rights Under USERRA
Familiarize yourself with the Uniformed Services Employment and Reemployment Rights Act (USERRA). This federal law ensures that service members cannot be required to use PTO for military leave and can take unpaid leave for military training, active duty, or other periods of service. USERRA also guarantees your right to return to work with the same seniority status and pay after your service.Document All Communications
Gather evidence of any discussions, written or verbal, in which your employer requested or required you to use PTO for military obligations. Save copies of emails, messages, or written memos that demonstrate the employer’s request. Keep a written record of any verbal communications, including dates, times, and details of the conversation. This documentation will be crucial if you need to file a formal complaint or lawsuit.Provide Advance Notice to Your Employer
If you have not already done so, provide advance notice of your military duty in writing to your employer in a timely manner. Though your employer cannot deny you military leave, this notice reinforces your intent to comply with USERRA’s guidelines.Speak Directly to Your Employer or HR
Politely inform your employer or HR representative of your rights under USERRA. Explain that USERRA protects your right to unpaid military leave and that you cannot be required to use PTO. Often, employers may be unaware of the law, and a clear conversation can resolve the issue.File a Complaint with the U.S. Department of Labor (DOL)
If your employer continues to insist on using PTO for military obligations, file a complaint with the Veterans’ Employment and Training Service (VETS), a branch of the DOL dedicated to protecting service members’ rights under USERRA. The DOL will investigate the complaint and work with you and your employer to resolve the situation.Seek Legal Assistance
If your employer does not cooperate after the DOL investigation or if the situation escalates, consider consulting an employment attorney with expertise in employment and reemployment rights. A lawyer can help you understand your options, guide you through filing a lawsuit, and assist in seeking damages for the PTO you were forced to use or any other losses incurred.Pursue Compensation for Damages
If your case goes to court and you are successful, you may be entitled to recover lost wages and benefits, emotional distress damages, and attorney’s fees. An attorney can help you understand the full scope of compensation you may be entitled to, including punitive damages if the employer’s actions were intentional or malicious.
Types of Damages and Compensation You May Be Entitled To
If you successfully file a claim or lawsuit for USERRA violations, you may be entitled to various types of compensation, including:
Lost Benefits and Wages: If you were forced to use PTO, you could recover those lost vacation days or the equivalent in financial compensation.
Emotional Distress Damages: In some cases, courts have awarded compensation for emotional distress related to an employer’s actions.
Attorney’s Fees and Court Costs: If you win your case, your employer may be ordered to cover your legal expenses, ensuring that you are not out of pocket for asserting your rights.
Punitive Damages: In rare cases, if an employer willfully violates USERRA, you may be entitled to punitive damages designed to discourage further violations.
FAQ Section
1. Can my employer require me to use PTO for National Guard duties?
No. Under USERRA, National Guard and reserve military personnel have the right to take unpaid leave for military service, though you can choose to use PTO if you prefer.
2. What if my employer claims they weren’t aware of USERRA?
Employers are responsible for understanding federal employment and reemployment rights laws. Claiming ignorance of USERRA does not exempt them from liability.
3. How do I provide notice of my military duty?
Give advance notice of your period of service in a timely manner, if possible, either verbally or in writing.
4. Can my employer deny my re-employment after military leave?
No. As long as you meet USERRA’s requirements for notification and duration, your reemployment rights entitle you to return to the same or equivalent position with the same seniority status and pay.
5. Are there protections for health plan coverage during service?
Yes. USERRA ensures that returning service members can retain their health plan coverage for a limited period if they pay the necessary premiums.
Knowing your rights under federal military leave laws and taking action when they are violated can protect your job and your future in both civilian and military roles.
Key Terms Defined: Understanding Military Leave and Reemployment Rights
Navigating legal protections under laws like USERRA can be easier with a clear understanding of the terms commonly used in these regulations. Here’s a glossary of key terms relevant to military leave and reemployment rights for service members:
Military Necessity
A requirement or duty that arises due to needs related to military operations, training, or national defense, often resulting in the activation or deployment of service members. This can mean unexpected or emergency mobilizations where military personnel are required to respond without delay.
National Emergency
A state of emergency is declared by the government in response to a significant threat or crisis that affects national security. During a national emergency, service members in the National Guard and other uniformed services may be called to serve on a voluntary or involuntary basis.
Uniformed Service
This term includes all branches of the U.S. military service: Army, Navy, Air Force, Marine Corps, Coast Guard, National Guard, and Reserves. It also covers the commissioned corps of the Public Health Service and certain members of the National Disaster Medical System (NDMS) who respond to public health emergencies.
Voluntary or Involuntary Basis
Service members may be activated for military duty on either a voluntary or involuntary basis. Voluntary service is chosen by the individual, while involuntary service is mandated by an order from the government or military authority, especially during times of military necessity or national emergency.
National Disaster Medical System (NDMS)
A federal program that provides medical response during disasters and emergencies, including support for healthcare facilities and patient evacuation. NDMS members are part of the uniformed services and are protected under USERRA, ensuring they retain employment and benefits if called to duty.
Services Employment and Reemployment
This refers to the legal rights and protections that guarantee service members the ability to return to their civilian jobs with the same seniority status and pay after completing military service. Under USERRA, these reemployment rights ensure that service members can remain secure in their civilian careers without being disadvantaged due to their period of service.
Making the Right Choice for Your Situation
Choosing to use PTO or unpaid leave is a personal decision. If you prefer saving PTO for personal time, USERRA allows unpaid leave, safeguarding your job security under employment and reemployment rights. For those on active duty or responding to a national emergency, USERRA offers peace of mind, ensuring a job to return to with benefits like health plan coverage intact.
In sum, federal military leave laws protect service members from using PTO involuntarily and allow flexibility, regardless of whether they’re fulfilling military necessity obligations or attending a training service session.
Do you feel pressured to use PTO or struggle to exercise your rights? Seeking guidance from an employment law attorney can clarify your options and reinforce the protections in place under the reemployment rights act.
If you believe your employer is forcing you to use PTO for military service, our team at Bourassa Law Group is here to help. With extensive experience in handling cases like yours, we’re committed to ensuring your rights under USERRA and related federal laws are fully upheld.
Contact us today for a free consultation, and let’s discuss how we can support you in securing the compensation and protection you deserve.
1-800-870-8910