What if the insurance company makes an offer that barely covers your expenses? Dealing with an insurance company after an accident or property damage can feel like navigating a maze designed to keep you lost. You expect a fair settlement, but the insurance company’s settlement offer often falls far short of what you deserve. When the insurer makes an unreasonably low settlement offer, you have legal recourse.
Understanding insurance law, your rights, and effective settlement negotiations can help you fight for a reasonable settlement. Whether you need compensation for medical expenses, lost wages, or property damage, knowing how to challenge an unfair insurance settlement offer empowers you to demand a fair and reasonable settlement.
If the insurer refuses to acknowledge the full extent of your claim, don’t settle for less. Let’s dive into the essential steps that can help you fight for the fair compensation you deserve.
Understanding Your Rights Under Insurance Law
Insurance law protects policyholders from unfair settlement offers. If an insurance company’s offer does not sufficiently cover your medical bills, lost income, or property damage, you have the right to challenge it under applicable insurance laws. Bad faith insurance laws exist to prevent insurers from taking advantage of accident victims.
Some key laws protecting policyholders include:
Unfair Claims Settlement Practices Act (UCSPA): This law prohibits insurers from misrepresenting insurance policy terms, delaying claims processing without a valid reason, or offering a lowball offer without justification.
Government Oversight: Agencies and state insurance departments oversee insurers to ensure compliance with fair settlement laws.
State-Specific Bad Faith Laws: Many states allow policyholders to sue insurers for acting in bad faith, meaning the insurer failed to provide a fair and reasonable settlement.
California, Colorado, and Nevada have legal avenues to challenge bad-faith insurance practices.
Below are brief overviews of each state’s relevant statutes:
California
California Insurance Code Section 790.03(h) defines unfair methods of competition and deceptive acts in the business of insurance, including certain unfair claims settlement practices.
Colorado
Colorado Revised Statutes Section 10-3-1115 prohibits insurers from unreasonably delaying or denying payment of a claim for benefits owed to a first-party claimant.
Nevada
Nevada Revised Statutes Chapter 686A addresses trade practices and frauds in the insurance industry, outlining unfair practices and defining standards for insurers.
These statutes empower policyholders to seek legal remedies when insurers fail to act in good faith.
Common Reasons for an Unfair Settlement Offer
Insurance adjusters often provide settlement amounts that do not reflect the full scope of an accident victim’s damages.
Common reasons include:
Lowball Initial Offer: An Insurance company’s first offer is often significantly lower than the claim’s fair value, pushing policyholders to accept less than they deserve.
Disputing Medical Expenses: Insurers may argue that certain medical care was unnecessary or specifically excluded from the insurance policy, even when the policyholder has a valid claim.
Underestimating Lost Wages and Lost Income: A fair settlement must include compensation for time missed at work and any potential loss of future earnings.
Depreciating Property Damage: Homeowners insurance and auto insurance policies may be subject to unfair depreciation calculations, reducing the settlement amount.
Claim Denials: Some insurers wrongfully deny valid claims, forcing policyholders to fight for fair compensation.
Steps to Challenge an Unfair Insurance Settlement Offer
1. Gather Evidence to Support Your Claim
To successfully dispute an unfair insurance settlement offer, you need detailed records and strong evidence, including:
Medical Records and Bills: Document all medical expenses related to the accident.
Property Damage Reports: Obtain estimates and repair invoices for property damage.
Proof of Lost Wages: Gather pay stubs, tax returns, and employer statements showing your lost income.
Accident Reports: Police reports or incident reports provide critical evidence.
Witness Statements: Statements from witnesses can support your claim.
2. Send a Demand Letter
A demand letter outlines why the insurance settlement offer is insufficient and provides evidence supporting a higher settlement amount.
Key points to include:
The full scope of your damages, including medical care, property damage, and lost wages.
Documentation proving the reasonable settlement amount.
A request for a fair offer within a certain date.
3. Negotiate with the Insurance Company
Settlement negotiations involve back-and-forth communication including multiple phone calls and emails with the insurance adjuster to push for a fair offer.
Use strong negotiation skills to:
Reject the first settlement offer if it is unfair.
Provide more evidence if the insurer disputes certain damages.
Emphasize the dollar value of medical expenses and lost income.
Court Cases Where Settlements Were Successfully Challenged
Numerous legal cases have resulted in policyholders overturning unfair insurance settlement offers. Some notable cases include:
Negrete v. Allianz Life Insurance Company of North America
In this case, plaintiffs alleged that Allianz engaged in deceptive practices related to the sale of deferred annuities to senior citizens. After extensive litigation, a settlement exceeding $250 million was reached, benefiting a nationwide class of senior citizens.
In re Prudential Insurance Company Sales Practices Litigation
Policyholders accused Prudential of employing fraudulent sales practices, including “churning” and misrepresentation of policy benefits. The court addressed these deceptive practices, leading to a substantial settlement for the affected policyholders.
Travelers Indemnity Co. v. Bailey
This case involved the enforcement of a settlement agreement related to asbestos litigation. The Supreme Court upheld the settlement, emphasizing the finality of bankruptcy court orders and reinforcing the binding nature of such agreements on all parties involved.
These cases exemplify instances where courts have addressed and rectified unfair settlement practices by insurers.
Government Agencies That Regulate Insurance Companies
Several government agencies oversee insurance companies to ensure fair settlement practices, including:
National Association of Insurance Commissioners (NAIC): Establishes national insurance standards.
Consumer Financial Protection Bureau (CFPB): Protects policyholders from unfair insurance practices.
State Insurance Departments: Each state has an insurance department that handles consumer complaints and enforces bad faith laws.
California Department of Insurance (CDI): Regulates insurers and investigates bad faith claims.
Colorado Division of Insurance (DOI): Oversees insurance practices and resolves disputes.
Nevada Division of Insurance (NDI): Ensures insurer compliance and assists consumers. Website
If you suspect an insurer is acting in bad faith, filing a complaint with these agencies can provide insight into your options.
When to Hire a Personal Injury Attorney
If you struggle to reach a fair settlement, hiring an experienced personal injury lawyer attorney can make a significant difference.
A personal injury lawyer can:
Handle negotiations with the insurance adjuster and ensure you don’t miss the time limit for filing a lawsuit.
Gather evidence to support your claim.
File a lawsuit if the insurer refuses to offer fair compensation.
Ensure the insurance settlement covers the full extent of your damages.
Fight for Fair Compensation
Challenging an unfair insurance settlement offer requires persistence, strong evidence, and legal knowledge. Insurance companies often try to minimize payouts, but you have the right to dispute an unreasonable offer. Understanding insurance law, gathering detailed records, and using negotiation skills can lead to a better outcome in your insurance settlement.
If negotiations fail, legal action becomes the last resort. Bourassa Law Group‘s lawyers are ready to fight for your rights. Our experienced attorneys have helped countless clients secure fair settlements. Contact us today for a free consultation and let us help you.
1-800-870-8910