Premises liability laws hold property owners accountable for injuries that occur due to unsafe conditions on their property. Many premises liability cases result in multi-million-dollar settlements due to the property owner’s negligence in addressing known hazards or failing to act quickly enough to prevent harm. Let’s take a look at these cases, their outcomes, and legal precedents.
Struggling with a similar case? Reach out to qualified premises liability attorneys at Bourassa Law Group.
Liebeck v. McDonald’s (Hot Coffee Case)
Incident:
In 1992, Stella Liebeck, a 79-year-old woman, sat in the passenger seat of her grandson’s car when she spilled a cup of McDonald’s coffee on her lap. McDonald’s had served the coffee at approximately 190°F (88°C), significantly hotter than the 140°F (60°C) typically offered by most coffee shops. The scalding liquid caused third-degree burns on six percent of Liebeck’s body, including her thighs, groin, and buttocks. Doctors hospitalized her for several days and performed skin grafts.
Outcome:
Liebeck initially requested a $20,000 settlement from McDonald’s to cover her medical expenses, but the company refused. In response, she filed a lawsuit. During the trial, evidence showed that McDonald’s had received over 700 reports of coffee-related burns in the previous decade, proving the company knew about the risk. The jury awarded Liebeck $2.7 million in punitive damages, though the judge later reduced it to $490,000. Ultimately, both parties reached a confidential settlement.
Legal Precedent:
Courts and legal scholars frequently reference this case in discussions about tort law, particularly regarding punitive damages. It underscores the responsibility businesses have in addressing known hazards, especially those that pose risks to customers.
Key Point:
The case illustrated how a business’s negligence—failing to mitigate known dangers—can result in significant financial consequences. The settlement went beyond medical expenses, penalizing McDonald’s for disregarding public safety.
2. Walmart Slip and Fall Lawsuit
Incident:
In 2014, Christine E., a shopper, slipped on a wet floor inside a Walmart store. The staff left the floor wet and failed to place warning signs to notify customers of the danger. Christine fell and suffered severe injuries, including back and knee injuries that required multiple surgeries and physical therapy.Outcome:
Christine filed a lawsuit against Walmart for premises liability, claiming the store was negligent in failing to maintain a safe environment. The lawsuit argued that the wet floor was a hazard that Walmart should have addressed by either cleaning the floor immediately or placing warning signs. After a lengthy legal battle, Walmart reached a $2.5 million settlement, which covered Christine’s medical expenses, lost wages, and pain and suffering.Key Point:
This case underlined the importance of property owners maintaining safe premises and responding to hazards promptly.
3. Hotel Balcony Collapse (New Orleans)
Incident:
In 2006, a balcony at a New Orleans hotel collapsed, causing severe injuries to several people. One of the victims, Richard D., sustained permanent spinal cord injuries and had to undergo extensive medical treatments. The balcony collapsed during a family gathering, and investigators later revealed that the hotel had failed to properly maintain it or adhere to safety codes. Inspectors found that the hotel had neglected proper inspections, allowing the wood to rot and ultimately cause the collapse.Outcome:
The family sued the hotel for premises liability, alleging that the hotel’s failure to maintain the building’s structural integrity caused the accident. The case resulted in an $8 million settlement, with a large portion going to cover Richard’s medical expenses and rehabilitation.Legal Precedent:
The case reinforced the idea that property owners have a responsibility to regularly inspect and maintain their premises, particularly structural elements like balconies. The lawsuit underscored that negligent maintenance can have devastating consequences.Key Point:
The hotel’s failure to maintain the property properly and adhere to safety codes resulted in catastrophic injuries. This case also demonstrates how courts can hold property managers liable for serious injuries resulting from poor maintenance and lack of inspections.
4. Six Flags Amusement Park Ride Malfunction
- Incident:
- In 2008, a malfunction on the “Superman: Tower of Power” ride at Six Flags amusement park in Illinois severely injured 22-year-old Matthew L. The ride’s cable snapped while pulling the car upward, causing Matthew to plummet several stories to the ground. The impact left him with serious brain and spinal injuries.
- Outcome:
- Matthew’s family sued Six Flags for negligence, arguing that the park had failed to properly maintain the ride. Investigators discovered that officials had previously flagged the ride for mechanical issues, but Six Flags had ignored the warnings. The family secured an $8.3 million settlement, covering Matthew’s medical expenses, long-term care, and compensation for the pain and suffering caused by his permanent injuries.
- Legal Precedent:
- This case set a strong precedent, emphasizing that amusement parks and entertainment venues must properly maintain their equipment to protect guests. It also underscored the responsibility of property owners to conduct regular inspections and address safety risks before accidents occur.
Key Point:
The failure to properly inspect and maintain amusement ride equipment led to a serious injury. It emphasizes the importance of regular maintenance schedules, particularly for high-risk operations such as amusement rides.
5. Apartment Complex Staircase Fall
Incident:
In 2011, Emily R., a 32-year-old woman, was severely injured after falling down a set of stairs in her apartment complex. The fall was caused by a defective handrail that had been broken for months. Emily had reported the issue to her landlord multiple times, but nothing was done to fix the handrail. The injuries she sustained required multiple surgeries, and she was left with permanent spinal damage.Outcome:
Emily filed a lawsuit against the property owner for failing to fix the handrail and for not maintaining safe conditions on the property. The court ruled in her favor, and the property owner reached a $7 million settlement. The settlement covered Emily’s medical expenses, rehabilitation costs, and compensation for her pain and suffering.Legal Precedent:
This case exemplifies landlord liability in premises liability lawsuits. Property owners must repair or replace hazardous conditions promptly. It also highlighted the responsibility of landlords to act when tenants report dangerous issues.Key Point:
The landlord’s failure to act on maintenance issues that were reported by the tenant led to significant financial and personal consequences. The case served as a reminder of the importance of landlords’ responsibilities to maintain safe living conditions for tenants.
FAQ: Premises Liability Lawsuits
What types of premises liability claims can be filed?
Common premises liability claims include slip and fall accidents, dog bites, swimming pool accidents, and injuries caused by hazardous conditions like broken stairs or inadequate security.
How can a skilled premises liability lawyer help with a lawsuit?
A skilled premises liability lawyer can prove negligence, gather evidence, and negotiate a fair settlement for medical expenses, lost wages, and pain and suffering caused by unsafe conditions.
What is the duty of care in premises liability cases?
Property owners must maintain a safe environment for visitors by fixing hazards, providing adequate security, and preventing foreseeable accidents.
Who can be held responsible for premises liability accidents?
Property owners are typically liable, but business owners, maintenance companies, and contractors may also share responsibility depending on the circumstances.
Can a property owner be held liable for criminal acts on their property?
Yes, courts can hold property owners liable if they fail to provide adequate security or neglect known risks that lead to criminal acts.
What should I do if I get injured on someone else’s property?
Document your injuries, seek medical treatment, and consult a premises liability attorney to determine if you have a valid compensation claim.
What are the most common causes of premises liability accidents?
Slip and falls, mechanical failures, unsafe property conditions, and inadequate security frequently cause premises liability accidents.
How do I determine if I have a valid premises liability claim?
You must prove that the property owner’s negligence directly caused your injury. An experienced lawyer can assess your case and gather the necessary evidence.
Can someone other than the property owner be held liable in a premises liability case?
Yes, business owners, contractors, or other responsible parties can be liable if their actions contributed to the hazardous conditions.
What are the legal obligations of property owners?
Property owners must maintain a reasonably safe environment, address hazards promptly, and take necessary precautions to prevent injuries.
How do premises liability lawyers help clients receive fair compensation?
Lawyers negotiate with insurance companies, prove negligence, and secure compensation for medical bills, lost wages, and pain and suffering.
What happens if a property owner knows about a dangerous condition?
If the property owner was aware of the danger but failed to fix it, they are more likely to be found negligent and held liable for injuries.
Are property owners always responsible for injuries on their property?
Not always. If the property owner took reasonable steps to prevent accidents or if the injured party acted negligently, the owner may not be held liable.
What are the different types of premises liability cases?
These cases include slip and falls, dog bites, unsafe working conditions, and injuries caused by negligent security or mechanical failures.
How can a premises liability attorney help in a slip and fall case?
An attorney can investigate the cause, gather evidence, and help secure compensation for medical treatment, lost wages, and pain caused by the fall. Hiring the right legal counsel matters. Ask your potential premises liability lawyer these 15 questions to ensure you make the right decision.
Seek Justice with Bourassa Law Group
The cases above highlight the simple fact that when property owners ignore safety measures or fail to properly maintain their premises, they can be held liable for resulting injuries, leading to significant financial consequences.
If you’re struggling with a premises liability case or have questions about your claim, don’t hesitate to reach out. At Bourassa Law Group, our seasoned premises liability lawyers are dedicated to achieving maximum compensation for your losses. In fact, our goal is to provide compassionate legal support and guidance tailored to your case.
Contact us today for a free consultation and take the first step in securing your future.
1-800-870-8910